It was the end of the day and we’d just finished reading. As other students started packing up, K. practically danced up to me, excitement sparking from every pore.
“Mrs. Hogan! Mrs. Hogan!” he exclaimed. “Did you know that hammerhead sharks can ride bikes and use parachutes!?!”
A brief silence ensued, as I pondered my response.
“Um… no, K, I did not know that,” I finally said. “Where did you learn that?”
“I read it in a book!” he beamed. “It was one of the “Who Would Win” ones!”
I paused again, debating how best to proceed. I’m more than prepared to admit I don’t know everything, and I learn interesting things from students all the time. Some of them are really quite surprising. In this instance, however, I felt pretty sure that some wires had gotten crossed.
I started slowly, feeling my way. “Wow! That’s definitely surprising. Do you know that when I read something in a book that’s really surprising, I often reread to make sure I understood correctly. Sometimes I’ve missed something or misunderstood something.”
“I have the book in my cubby!” he said. I’ll go get it!” He dashed away.
A few moments later he was back at my side. He immediately began to leaf through the pages of his book. Another student asked me something and I turned to talk with them. When I turned back, there was K, book in hand, sparks noticeably dimmed.
“Oh,” he said, looking up at me. “It says can’t.” He pointed to the page and read aloud, “Things Hammerhead Sharks Can’t Do. They can’t parachute. They can’t sing like Elvis. They can’t ride a bicycle.”
“Yeah,” I said. “Small words can make a big difference when you’re reading.”
We had a moment before the buses were called for him to leaf through his book and show me a few of the amazing things that hammerhead sharks can do, but soon afterward, the book was back in his cubby and we were headed out to the buses.
I’ve been thinking about this a lot since it happened. I know that I’m responsible for teaching K to read accurately and think about what he’s reading. Still, I feel a bit like I pulled the wings off of a butterfly. He had been practically floating along with delight, imagining a wonder-filled world with bike-riding, parachuting hammerhead sharks. There’s something so gloriously innocent about that (even as it raises a few pointed questions about critical thinking skills).
As his teacher, I couldn’t ignore his error, but wow, I hated being responsible for dimming down his glow.

























